Constitutional Amendment IV

Aside from any room for interpretation of the word “unreasonable” Amendment IV is pretty simple:

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.

Our government and its officers have no right or authority to seize our persons, houses, papers, or effects without cause supported by a claim of the particulars of who or what may be seized and where the seizure may occur.

Posted

2009-05-19

General

David

Tags:

amendments, Bill of Rights, Constitution, documents, history, liberty

Comments

6 responses to “Constitutional Amendment IV”

Reach Upward

2009-05-19

Is having a black and white image of your, your wife’s, your child’s, or your grandmother’s naked body viewed by a TSA government contractor as a condition of commercial air travel — all in the name of national security — an unreasonable search? The government doesn’t think so.

Reply
1. David
  
  2009-05-19
  
  I consider it to be an unreasonable search. Those body image scanners should be absolutely limited to optional secondary search – in other words I do not object to the TSA using those as an option that travelers may choose to use in lieu of a pat-down. Any requirement that travelers submit to those machines is an unreasonable search.
  
  Reply
Reach Upward

2009-05-20

How often is a pat-down threatened? How often are such threats warranted?

Reply
1. David
  
  2009-05-21
  
  The pat-downs are threatened every time some level of probable cause is established (when someone sets off the metal detectors) plus each time someone is “randomly picked” for enhanced screening (which would violate the principle of “probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation”).
  
  I wish I knew the statistics, but I would be surprised if the pat-downs turned out to be warranted once in every 1000 times they are conducted.
  
  Reply
Reach Upward

2009-05-21

Somehow I’m not comforted by simply trusting the government to do the right thing.

Reply
1. David
  
  2009-05-21
  
  Neither am I.
  
  Reply

Constitutional Amendment IV

Comments

6 responses to “Constitutional Amendment IV”

Leave a Reply Cancel reply